PylotED

PylotED / Evidence-informed decisions

Start with a need.Finish with evidence.

A practical guide to Digital Promise’s EdTech Procurement Framework—six stages that connect district priorities, meaningful Pilots, and informed purchasing decisions.

Six stages. One connected process.

The summaries below follow Digital Promise’s framework. The team questions and suggested records are PylotED’s practical interpretation.

01

Analyze & Inventory

Bring departments and educators together to identify instructional gaps and the learners most affected. Review existing tools, usage, and overlap before deciding whether another product is needed.

Ask your team

What problem are we solving—and what do we already have?

Suggested records to prepare
  • A specific instructional need and intended learner population.
  • An inventory of current tools, contracts, usage, and duplication.
  • A short rationale for exploring a new solution.
02

Discover & Decide

Compare products against shared criteria for instructional fit, evidence, technical compatibility, privacy, security, and cost. Keep the identified learning need at the center of selection.

Ask your team

Which option has a credible case for meeting our need?

Suggested records to prepare
  • A consistent selection rubric and product comparison.
  • Research and evidence relevant to the district’s context.
  • Documented technical, privacy, and financial review questions.
03

Design & Plan

Agree on what success means before the Pilot starts. Define measures, expected use, professional learning, responsibilities, and a timeline with educators, school leaders, and the vendor.

Ask your team

What evidence will help us make a decision?

Suggested records to prepare
  • Success criteria, baseline measures, and a collection schedule.
  • Participants, dates, training plans, and named owners.
  • Expected frequency and duration of use, with checkpoints.
04

Mobilize & Implement

Help educators translate recommended use into classroom practice. Provide ongoing support, monitor implementation, and use regular check-ins to resolve barriers and adjust the plan.

Ask your team

Is the Pilot being carried out as intended?

Suggested records to prepare
  • Training and support records.
  • Actual use compared with the planned amount of use.
  • Feedback, implementation barriers, and changes made along the way.
05

Evaluate & Reflect

Compare results with the original success criteria. Interpret learning outcomes and participant experiences together, involving educators and learners, and identify improvements for future Pilots.

Ask your team

What changed, for whom, and how confident are we?

Suggested records to prepare
  • Results for each success criterion and the supporting evidence.
  • Participant perspectives that explain or challenge the findings.
  • Limitations, missing evidence, and lessons for the next Pilot.
06

Sustain & Scale

Share the findings and recommendation with decision-makers and the community. If expansion is justified, plan its scope, support, and contract expectations. A poor fit can also be a useful result.

Ask your team

What should we do next—and what supports that choice?

Suggested records to prepare
  • A recommendation with evidence and an explanation of tradeoffs.
  • A targeted or phased rollout plan when appropriate.
  • Budget, support expectations, and future review criteria.

The PylotED perspective

Make the evidence
easy to follow.

A useful Pilot tells a connected story: the need, the plan, what happened, what the team learned, and the decision that follows.

Keep these three questions visible throughout your review:

Was it used?

Participation and implementation help explain the conditions of the Pilot.

Did it help?

Outcomes and participant feedback address the original goals.

What is missing?

Incomplete evidence should stay visible. Missing data is not a negative result.

Take the next step with your team.

Use this overview to start the conversation. Visit Digital Promise for the complete guidance, templates, and resources behind each stage.

Explore Digital Promise